How IPO Guru rates
We check what really happened to the IPO after an analyst gave a call. We don't go by name or popularity. All numbers on our analyst pages come from the method below.
The analyst score
We look at every Apply, May Apply, Neutral and Avoid call on IPOs that got listed in the last 18 months. New calls count more than old ones. Mainboard and SME IPOs are checked separately.
Hit
Was the call right? We check every call two times: on listing day and 180 days after listing. If the IPO is not 180 days old yet, we use today's price. Bigger gains on an Apply call, or bigger falls on an Avoid call, get more marks. See how marks are given.
Selectivity
Did the IPOs the analyst liked do better than the IPOs they said Avoid or Neutral to? This counts only when the analyst has given some Avoid or Neutral calls. If an analyst gives only Apply calls, this part is skipped. It does not go for or against them.
Coverage
How many IPOs did the analyst give a call on (Apply, May Apply, Neutral or Avoid)? Covering 75% or more of the IPOs gets full marks. Reviewing only a few easy IPOs gets fewer marks.
Compared with the market
Each part gets marks out of 100. 50 marks means the analyst did the same as someone who simply applies in every IPO. Above 50 is better, below 50 is worse.
To make the gap easy to see, we double the distance from 50 in the final score. For example, if an analyst's marks add up to 60, the final score is 70.
Today, applying in every mainboard IPO would get a score of 61. Anyone above that has beaten the market.
Fair to analysts with few calls
Analysts with only a few calls are kept close to the middle until they give more calls. So a few lucky calls cannot put anyone on top.
- Less than 10 listed calls in the last 12 months: Early Track, no rank yet.
- Top Performer needs at least 25 calls.
- More than half the calls Neutral: marked Low Conviction.
No late callsReviews published after the IPO closes are not counted.
No conflictIf the analyst's own group managed the IPO, that call is not counted.
Call is lockedThe call is fixed when the IPO closes. Changing it later does not help.
Same time periodEvery call is checked over the same 180 days. Scores update every hour.
Example: Nirmal Bang
The current #1 on our analyst ranking, with 31 listed calls.
| Part | What happened | Marks | Weight |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hit | 80% of calls were right on listing day. Average marks per call: 77, against 61.5 for applying in every IPO. | 70 | 80% |
| Selectivity | No Avoid or Neutral calls, so this part is skipped. | – | 10% |
| Coverage | Gave a call on 22% of IPOs since its first call. | 50 | 10% |
Total marks come to about 67.9, so the final score is 86/100. See the full profile →
What the score means
| 80–100 | Top Performer — Among the best calls over a long time. Needs at least 25 calls. |
| 72–79 | Reliable Analyst — Clearly better than applying in every IPO. |
| 66–71 | Above Market — A little better than applying in every IPO. |
| 50–65 | Market Average — About the same as applying in every IPO. |
| 0–49 | Below Market — Worse than applying in every IPO. |
See the ranking: IPO analysts
The IPO consensus score
Every IPO page shows one consensus score. It is made from all the analyst calls on that IPO. Analysts with a better track record get more weight.
How calls are counted
Apply = 100 marks, May Apply = 60, Neutral = 40 and Avoid = 0. Then each call gets extra weight as per the analyst's rank (Mainboard rank for mainboard IPOs, SME rank for SME IPOs):
- Rank 1 to 3: counted 3 times
- Rank 4 to 6: 2.5 times
- Rank 7 to 10: 2 times
- Rank 11 to 20: 1.6 times, rank 21 to 30: 1.3 times
- All others, including Early Track: 1 time
What the consensus score means
| 85+ | Strong Apply |
| 67–84 | Apply |
| 55–66 | May Apply |
| 45–54 | Neutral |
| 21–44 | Avoid |
| Below 21 | Strictly Avoid |
How each call is marked
First we see how much the IPO gained or lost, and put it in one of four groups. Then we give marks based on what the analyst said. We do this two times, on listing day and after 180 days, and take the average.
Step 1: Gain groups
| Big win | Gain of 25% or more |
| Win | Gain between 10% and 25% |
| Flat | Between 10% loss and 10% gain |
| Bad | Loss of more than 10% |
Gain or loss is counted from the IPO's issue price.
Step 2: Marks for each call
| Call | Big win | Win | Flat | Bad |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Apply | 100 | 80 | 4045 after 180 days | 0 |
| May Apply | 75 | 6065 after 180 days | 45 | 10 |
| Neutral | 4035 after 180 days | 50 | 8085 after 180 days | 4035 after 180 days |
| Avoid | 0 | 2025 after 180 days | 4070 after 180 days | 100 |
Marks are out of 100. Where the small number is shown, the marks after 180 days are a little different.
Examples
- Analyst said Apply and the IPO listed 30% up (Big win): 100 marks.
- Analyst said Apply and the IPO listed 15% down (Bad): 0 marks.
- Analyst said Avoid and the IPO fell 12% (Bad): 100 marks.
- Analyst said Neutral and the IPO listed flat: 80 marks.
- An Apply call that listed 30% up but was 15% down after 180 days gets (100 + 0) ÷ 2 = 50 marks.
What the calls mean
What each analyst call means for you as an investor.
Strong yes. The analyst thinks the company is good or the price is attractive.
Yes, but with some risk. Suitable if you can take more risk.
No clear view. The analyst says wait and watch the subscription or listing.
Don't apply. The analyst sees risk in the price, business or management.